11 Instant Pot Creamy Egg Nog!

Egg nog is a favorite around the holidays. If you are concerned about using raw eggs in egg nog, you may want to try this 'cooked' or custard version. Cooking your eggs will ensure that your egg nog is free from any salmonella bacteria, which is great if you have guests that are young, pregnant, or elderly. It is important to use fresh eggs and fresh milk with this recipe. What works even better is using superfine sugar and freshly grated nutmeg.

This recipe is super easy, as you don't have to separate your egg/egg whites, or whip up some heavy cream to add later.

Let's get started!

This is a cool tip, and one that you will want to use for this recipe and for when you make yogurt in your Instant Pot.

Put several ice cubes into your pot. This will help prevent your milk mixture from scorching or sticking to your pot. I didn't believe it till I tried it. Here's the science behind it:

"This will pre-coat the metal surface with water molecules and the coat will protect the surface from direct contact with the milk proteins when you pour the milk in. When the pot becomes heated, the molecules take longer to contact the hot metal and bond to it. So less protein sticks to the bottom of the pan and scorches." - NYT Yogurt Making Tips 

Dump out the ice cubes and water, but don't wipe the pot dry.

In a separate bowl, whisk your eggs.

Add your sugar. I started with 3/4 cup. If you have superfine sugar, that will mix in and dissolve more readily. If you want to use honey, you may want to add it after your milk has heated, as it will dissolve more easily.

Add your milk. I used 1%, but you can use any milk percentage you want. Whole milk will give you the creamiest texture.

Pour your mixture into the Instant Pot. Close the lid, the vent, and select Yogurt, then Adjust. Your display should read Boil. Yogurt and More will light up.

When the cycle is complete, take the temperature with an instant read thermometer. It should read at least 160°F. If not, select Saute, Adjust to Low, and stir the milk till you reach 160°F. This will give you a custard style egg nog and help thicken it.

Pour the milk mixture over a fine mesh sieve that is set inside a bowl or 8 cup glass measuring cup.

Scrape out the cooked egg mixture from the bottom. Don't worry! The ice cubes have prevented the egg/sugar mixture from scorching and sticking. The egg mixture is very soft.

Push all of the the egg mixture through the sieve. Don't worry, your egg not will not be lumpy. It will be smooth and creamy. You may need to scrape the bottom of the sieve to continue.

*One reader doesn't use a sieve - she simply puts in in her BlendTec mixer until smooth and creamy.

Add your half and half to the warm egg/milk mixture. Stir till combined.

Add vanilla extract (I make vanilla extract in the pressure cooker!) and ground nutmeg. If you have access to a microplane zester and fresh nutmeg, go for it. The taste and aroma will be incredible!

Put this mixture into a covered pitcher or container and chill for several hours or over night.
Shake or stir before serving.


print recipe

Instant Pot Creamy Egg Nog
Enjoy a glass of creamy egg nog, using the Yogurt setting on your Instant Pot! For the creamiest egg nog, use a combination of whole milk with heavy cream of half & half milk.
Recipe Note: You can use any milk that fits your dietary needs. You may need to adjust the amount of sugar based on taste and if your milk is naturally sweet. 
  • 6 eggs (fresh is better)
  • 1/2-1 cup granulated sugar, depending on your taste. I used 3/4 cup
  • 2 cups fresh milk (whole milk will give you the creamiest texture)
  • 2 cups half & half milk, or heavy cream (heavy cream will make it thicker)
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 1/4-1/2 teaspoon ground nutmeg
  • 4-6 ice cubes
  • Fine meshed sieve
1. In a medium sized bowl, whisk the eggs.2. Add sugar, whisk to dissolve.3. Stir in 2 cups milk, mix well and set aside. 4. Put the ice cubes in the pressure cooker insert. Swirl the ice cubes to cover the bottom of the pot. Empty the ice cubes and the water, but do not dry the insert. 5. Pour in the egg mixture into the insert and put insert into the pressure cooker. 6. Close the pressure cooker, and close the pressure valve. Instead of using the pressure cooker lid, you can use a dinner plate, lid from your pots, or a flat silicone suction lid.  7. Select Yogurt More (boil) setting according to your model. The Ultra uses (HIGH or Customize setting) and will take about 20-25 minutes.
8. Open the pressure cooker, whisk, and take the temperature. If the temperature reads 160°F or higher, remove the insert from the cooker. If the temp is less, use the Saute Normal setting, and whisk until you reach this temperature.
9. Set a fine mesh sieve over a large bowl.* Put the hot egg/milk mixture into the sieve, pushing the egg mixture through with a silicone spatula or spoon. *You can use a blender to mix the egg nog, instead of a sieve.
10. Stir in the half & half milk or heavy cream. Add vanilla extract and nutmeg.
Pour egg nog into a covered pitcher or container and chill for several hours or over night. Egg nog will stay fresh in the fridge for 4-5 days. 
Prep time: Cook time: Total time: 40Yield: 6 cups


  1. Can you flavor it like with cinnamon? If so when do u do it? Should we use ground cinnamon or cinnamon oil like louann oils?

    1. Yes. Add it as described in step 10 along with your half & half milk or cream and chill. 🙂

  2. Any idea on the calories ?

    1. It depends on the milks you use. You can put the ingredients into MyFitnessPal and it will determine the nutritional information for you. 🙂

  3. Can you do this in the Duo? I dont have a yogurt button.

    1. If you have a Duo Crisp that has no Yogurt setting, you can use the Sous Vide setting set to 160°F. :-)

  4. If you don't have the yogurt button what do you push

    1. I would use Saute Low, stirring constantly, until the 160°F temperature is reached. :-)

  5. I made this today. So rich and creamy and delicious. This will be my go-to recipe for eggnog from now on. I can't stand the store- bought eggnog. It tastes so artificial. I put one cup of sugar. Next time I will cut back on the sugar. Too sweet for my taste as I've cut sugar out of almost everything I eat nowadays. thanks for the recipe

    1. I'm glad you enjoyed my egg nog recipe - I agree that it tastes much better than store bought egg nog. It's great that we can adjust this recipe to meet our dietary needs, whether it be reducing the sugar or using a lactose free milk. Enjoy! :-)

  6. Haha you forgot the dark rum and brandy, my mom put in hers!


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Pin It button on image hover